📍 School Code: 220736 | Samdari, Balotra, Rajasthan 📧 gsssjethantri@gmail.com
Chapter 3 · First Flight · Class 10

Two Stories about Flying

His First Flight & Black Aeroplane

Story A: His First Flight

Author: Liam O'Flaherty

"His First Flight" is the story of a young seagull who is afraid to fly. The story explores the theme of overcoming fear through necessity, hunger, and family encouragement. It is a simple yet powerful story about taking the first step — how fear can be conquered when there is no other choice.

The Seagull's Fear

A young seagull stands alone on a ledge overlooking the vast sea. His two brothers and his sister have already learned to fly. They had all run to the brink of the ledge and flapped their wings and flown away. But this young seagull could not muster the courage to take the plunge. He was terrified that his wings would not support him and he would fall down into the sea and drown. His parents scolded him, threatened him, and even left him alone on the ledge to force him to fly — but he remained frozen with fear.

Hunger as the Catalyst

For twenty-four hours, nobody came to feed the young seagull. He was desperately hungry. He watched his family eating — his mother was tearing pieces of fish and feeding his brothers and sister. He begged his mother for food, crying plaintively. His mother picked up a piece of fish and flew towards him. She came close to the ledge — so tantalisingly close — but she did not land. She hung in the air just out of his reach, the fish dangling from her beak.

The Moment of Flight

Maddened by hunger, the young seagull dived at the fish. He fell outward and downward into space. A monstrous terror seized him, and his heart stood still. But the next instant, his wings spread outward automatically. He could feel the tips of his wings cutting through the air. He was flying! He was soaring, gliding, banking, and turning. His family screamed with joy and praised him. He had finally overcome his fear — not through courage alone, but through the sheer force of hunger and the instinctive will to survive.

The seagull then made his first landing on the sea. His legs sank into the water, and he screamed with fright — he thought he would sink. But his belly touched the water and he floated. He was safe. His family gathered around him, offering him scraps of dog-fish. He had taken his first flight.

Key Themes — His First Flight

  • Overcoming Fear: The central message — fear is natural, but it can be conquered. Sometimes we need a push (or extreme necessity) to take that first leap.
  • Family Support: The family's tough love — refusing to feed him, encouraging him from a distance — ultimately helps the seagull overcome his fear.
  • Self-Discovery: The seagull discovers that he had the ability to fly all along; it was only fear that held him back.
  • Instinct and Nature: When pushed to the extreme, natural instincts take over. The wings spread automatically once the seagull took the plunge.

Story B: Black Aeroplane

Author: Frederick Forsyth

"Black Aeroplane" is a mysterious and suspenseful story about a pilot who encounters a strange, unexplained event while flying through a storm. The story raises questions about the supernatural, faith, and the unknown forces that sometimes guide us.

The Pilot's Journey

The narrator is a pilot flying his old Dakota DS 088 aeroplane over France, heading back to England. It is a beautiful night — the moon is coming up behind him, and the stars are shining in the clear sky. He is looking forward to being with his family, having a good English breakfast of eggs, bacon, and coffee. Everything seems perfect.

The Storm

As he crosses the French coast, he suddenly sees huge storm clouds ahead of him — enormous, towering, dark clouds that looked like black mountains. He knows he does not have enough fuel to fly around them. He should turn back to Paris, but he does not want to — he wants to get home. So he makes the risky decision to fly straight into the storm.

The Mysterious Black Aeroplane

Inside the storm, everything goes wrong. The compass spins wildly, the radio is dead, and he cannot see anything in the thick, dark clouds. He is lost, with no instruments and no way to communicate. Just when he is about to give up hope, he sees another aeroplane — a black aeroplane with no lights, flying next to him. The pilot of the black aeroplane waves at him, as if to say "Follow me." With no other option, the narrator follows the mysterious black plane through the storm clouds.

The Safe Landing

After flying through the storm for about half an hour, the black aeroplane begins to descend. The narrator follows and suddenly sees the runway lights of an airport below. He lands safely. He has only enough fuel for five or ten more minutes of flying. The black aeroplane had saved his life.

After landing, the narrator goes to the control tower to ask about the other pilot and thank him. But the woman at the control tower tells him something shocking: "There was no other aeroplane." No other plane was seen on the radar that night. The black aeroplane and its pilot remain a complete mystery.

Key Themes — Black Aeroplane

  • Mystery and the Supernatural: Who was the pilot of the black aeroplane? A guardian angel? A hallucination? The story deliberately leaves this unanswered.
  • Risk and Decision-Making: The pilot's risky decision to fly through the storm instead of turning back raises questions about judgment vs. desire.
  • Faith and Guidance: Sometimes help comes from unexpected, inexplicable sources. The story suggests that there are forces beyond human understanding.
  • The Unknown: Not everything can be explained by logic and science. Some events remain mysteries, and we must accept that.

Poem 1: How to Tell Wild Animals

Poet: Carolyn Wells

Stanza 1

If ever you should go by chance

To jungles in the east;

And if there should to you advance

A large and tawny beast,

If he roars at you as you're dyin'

You'll know it is the Asian Lion.

The poet humorously says that if you happen to visit an eastern jungle and a large, tawny (yellowish-brown) beast approaches you and roars at you so loudly that you feel you are dying, you can be sure it is an Asian Lion. The humour lies in the absurd method of identification — you recognize the animal only when it is about to kill you.

Stanza 2

Or if some time when roaming round,

A noble wild beast greets you,

He'll kill you just for fun, you know,

Because if he'll just hug you very tight

And say, "Well, well, that's great!

If this should happen, you'll soon find out—

This fellow's called the Asiatic Bear.

If a noble wild beast "greets" you and hugs you so tight that you die, it is the Bengal Tiger. The poet uses dark humour — the tiger "greets" you by eating you. The word "noble" is ironic when applied to an animal that kills you.

Stanza 3

If strolling forth, a beast you view,

Whose hide with spots is peppered,

As soon as he has lept on you,

You'll know it is the Leopard.

Twill do no good to roar with pain,

He'll only lep and lep again.

If you see a beast with a spotted hide and it leaps on you, you will know it is a Leopard. Roaring with pain will not help — the leopard will only leap again and again. The poet uses the humorous misspelling "lep" (for "leapt") and the repetition "lep and lep again" for comic effect.

Stanzas 4-6 (Summary)

The remaining stanzas continue in the same humorous vein. The poet describes how to identify a crocodile (it has tears while eating you — "crocodile tears"), a hyena (it laughs while attacking — merry smile), and a chameleon (a small creature that sits on a tree and has no ears, no wings, and no legs visible — it changes colour). The final identification tip: if there is nothing on the tree, a chameleon is there — you just cannot see it.

Central Theme

The poem is a light-hearted, humorous take on identifying wild animals. The irony is that the "identification method" requires getting attacked or killed by the animal first. The poet uses dark humour, irony, and wit to entertain the reader while also subtly reminding us of the dangerous nature of wild animals.

Literary Devices

  • Humour / Irony: Dark Humour The entire poem is built on ironic humour — identifying animals by how they kill you.
  • Satire: The poet satirizes the idea of "guidebooks" for wild animals by making the identification process absurdly dangerous.
  • Rhyme Scheme: Regular rhyme scheme (aabb/abab) gives the poem a playful, song-like quality despite its dark content.
  • Personification: Animals are given human qualities — the tiger "greets" you, the hyena smiles "merrily."
  • Repetition: "Lep and lep again" — repeated for comic emphasis.

Poem 2: The Ball Poem

Poet: John Berryman

What is the boy now, who has lost his ball,

What, what is he to do? I saw it go

Merrily bouncing, down the street, and then

Merrily over — there it is in the water!

No use to say 'O there are other balls':

An ultimate shaking grief fixes the boy

As he stands rigid, trembling, staring down

All his young days into the harbour where

His ball went. I would not intrude on him;

A dime, another ball, is worthless. Now

He senses first responsibility

In a world of possessions. People will take

Balls, balls will be lost always, little boy.

And no one buys a ball back. Money is external.

He is learning, well behind his desperate eyes,

The epistemology of loss, how to stand up

Knowing what every man must one day know

And most know many days, how to stand up.

Explanation

A boy loses his ball — it bounces down the street and falls into the water (harbour). The poet observes the boy's reaction. The boy is rigid, trembling, staring at the harbour where his ball disappeared. The poet understands that saying "there are other balls" or offering money for a new one is meaningless. This is not just about a ball — it is about the boy's first experience of loss.

The ball represents the boy's childhood, innocence, and all the memories associated with it. When it is lost, no replacement can fill that void. The poet says the boy is learning the "epistemology of loss" — the knowledge and understanding of what it means to lose something you value. He is learning that in life, things will be taken away, possessions will be lost, and money cannot buy back what truly matters.

The poem ends with the powerful phrase "how to stand up" — repeated to emphasize that the greatest lesson in life is learning to cope with loss and still carry on. The boy must learn to stand up, accept the loss, and move forward.

Central Theme

The poem is about the universal experience of loss and the process of growing up. The ball is a metaphor for anything valuable that we lose in life — childhood innocence, relationships, opportunities. The poet conveys that loss is inevitable, money is "external" and cannot replace what is truly lost, and the most important lesson is learning how to bear loss with resilience — how to "stand up."

Literary Devices

  • Metaphor: The Ball The ball is a metaphor for childhood, innocence, and cherished memories — things that cannot be replaced once lost.
  • Imagery: "Merrily bouncing, down the street" — visual imagery of the ball's carefree movement, contrasting with the boy's grief.
  • Repetition: "How to stand up" is repeated to emphasize the central lesson — resilience in the face of loss.
  • Enjambment: Lines flow into each other, mirroring the continuous, unstoppable nature of loss and the passage of time.
  • Alliteration: "Balls, balls will be lost" — repetition of the 'b' sound.
  • Symbolism: The harbour symbolizes the vast, irretrievable past where lost things sink beyond recovery.

NCERT Solutions — His First Flight

Thinking about the Text

Q1. Why was the young seagull afraid to fly? Do you think all young birds are afraid to make their first flight, or are some birds born with the ability to fly?

The young seagull was afraid to fly because he felt that his wings would not support him and he would fall into the sea and drown. When he looked down from the ledge, the vast expanse of the sea far below terrified him. While all his brothers and sister had taken the plunge, he remained paralysed by fear. It is natural for young birds to feel hesitant — no bird is born knowing how to fly. They have the instinct to fly, but the first flight requires overcoming the fear of the unknown. The story shows that with the right motivation (in this case, hunger), the instinct takes over and the bird discovers it could fly all along.

Q2. "The sight of the food maddened him." What does this suggest? What compelled the young seagull to finally fly?

This line suggests that the young seagull was extremely hungry — so hungry that the sight of food made him lose all rational thought and caution. He had not eaten for twenty-four hours. When his mother flew towards him with a piece of fish, dangling it tantalisingly just out of reach, the seagull's hunger overpowered his fear. He dived at the fish without thinking about the consequences. This moment of desperation — driven by the basic survival instinct of hunger — compelled him to take the leap. His wings spread automatically, and he discovered he could fly. The lesson is that sometimes our deepest fears can be overcome when we are driven by a force stronger than fear itself.

Q3. "They were beckoning to him, calling shrilly." Why did the seagull's father and mother threaten him and cajole him to fly?

The parents used a combination of threats, scolding, and cajoling (coaxing) because they knew their son had the ability to fly but was being held back purely by fear. They understood that the only way to make him fly was to force him into a situation where he had no other choice. They stopped feeding him, left him alone on the ledge, and tried every possible way to push him to take the first step. This "tough love" approach was born out of genuine concern — they knew that a seagull that cannot fly cannot survive. Their seemingly harsh behaviour was actually the most loving thing they could do for their child.

NCERT Solutions — Black Aeroplane

Q4. "I'll take the risk." What is the risk? Why does the narrator take it?

The risk is flying straight into the massive storm clouds that lay ahead of the narrator's path. He knew it was dangerous — the clouds were enormous, dark, and threatening. The safe option would have been to turn back to Paris. However, the narrator did not want to turn back because he was eager to get home. He was dreaming of his family and a good English breakfast. He also did not have enough fuel to fly around the storm. So, driven by a combination of homesickness and limited fuel, he took the risky decision to fly through the storm. This decision nearly proved fatal, as he lost all instruments and communication inside the clouds.

Q5. Describe the narrator's experience as he flew the aeroplane into the storm.

As the narrator flew into the storm, everything went wrong very quickly. The sky turned completely dark. He could see nothing outside the aeroplane. His compass started spinning wildly — it was useless. He tried to contact the radio for help, but it was dead. He was completely lost — no instruments, no visibility, no communication. He was flying blind in thick, black storm clouds with no idea of his direction or altitude. Panic set in. Then, suddenly, he saw the black aeroplane flying beside him. The mysterious pilot waved at him to follow. With no other hope, the narrator followed the black aeroplane for half an hour until he saw the runway lights and landed safely.

Q6. Who do you think helped the narrator to reach safely? Discuss this among yourselves and give reasons for your answer.

This is the central mystery of the story, and it is deliberately left unanswered by the author. Several interpretations are possible:

1. A guardian angel or supernatural being: The black aeroplane appeared at exactly the right moment, had no lights, was not visible on radar, and vanished without a trace. This suggests something beyond normal explanation.

2. The narrator's own subconscious/instinct: Under extreme stress, the narrator may have subconsciously guided himself to safety, imagining the black aeroplane as a coping mechanism.

3. An unexplained phenomenon: The author, Frederick Forsyth, seems to suggest that there are forces in this world that we cannot explain — and that sometimes help comes from the most unexpected and inexplicable sources.

The story's power lies in the fact that the mystery is never solved. The reader is left to wonder and draw their own conclusions.

NCERT Solutions — How to Tell Wild Animals

Q7. Does the poet use humour and irony in the poem "How to Tell Wild Animals"? Give examples.

Yes, the entire poem is built on humour and irony. The poet uses dark comedy to describe dangerous situations in a light, amusing way:

Humour: The poet suggests that the best way to identify a wild animal is by how it attacks or kills you. For example, if a large beast roars at you so fiercely that you feel you are dying, you know it is an Asian Lion. If a beast "greets" you by killing you, it is a Bengal Tiger. This absurd method of identification is inherently funny.

Irony: The title itself is ironic — "How to Tell Wild Animals" sounds like a helpful guide, but the "methods" described would result in your death. The irony is that by the time you have identified the animal, it is too late to do anything about it. The poet also uses ironic expressions like "a noble wild beast" for a tiger that kills you, and the crocodile's "tears" (crocodile tears being famously fake).

NCERT Solutions — The Ball Poem

Q8. Why does the poet say, "I would not intrude on him"? Why doesn't he offer him money to buy another ball?

The poet says "I would not intrude on him" because he understands that the boy is going through an important life lesson — the experience of loss. Interfering would deprive the boy of this essential learning moment. The poet does not offer money for a new ball because "money is external" — it can buy a new ball but cannot replace the memories, emotions, and attachment associated with the lost ball. The boy needs to learn that some things in life are irreplaceable. The poet recognizes that the boy is learning the "epistemology of loss" — understanding what loss truly means and how to cope with it. This is a lesson that cannot be taught by others; it must be experienced personally.

Q9. What does "epistemology of loss" mean in the context of the poem?

"Epistemology of loss" means the knowledge and understanding of what it means to lose something. Epistemology is the branch of philosophy concerned with how we know things. In the poem, the boy is not just losing a ball — he is gaining knowledge about the nature of loss itself. He is learning that possessions can be taken away, that not everything can be replaced with money, and that the most important skill in life is learning to "stand up" after experiencing loss. This phrase captures the deep, philosophical dimension of what appears to be a simple childhood incident.

Q10. What is the boy learning from the loss of his ball? What will this experience teach him?

The boy is learning several crucial life lessons from this seemingly small incident:

1. Impermanence: Things do not last forever. Possessions can be lost at any time.

2. Irreplaceability: Some things — memories, emotions, attachments — cannot be bought back with money. "Money is external."

3. Resilience: The most important lesson is how to "stand up" after a loss. Life will bring many losses, and the ability to cope and carry on is essential.

4. Responsibility: The boy "senses first responsibility / In a world of possessions" — he begins to understand that he is responsible for his own belongings and his own emotional well-being.

This experience will teach him to face future losses — bigger and more significant ones — with strength and maturity.

Question Bank

Multiple Choice Questions (MCQs)

1. What motivated the young seagull to finally fly?
  • A) His father pushed him off the ledge
  • B) He saw his siblings flying and felt jealous
  • C) Hunger — he dived at food his mother held near the ledge
  • D) A strong wind carried him away
Correct: C) Hunger — The seagull had not eaten for 24 hours. When his mother dangled fish just out of reach, hunger overcame his fear and he dived at the food, discovering he could fly.
2. What type of aeroplane was the narrator flying in "Black Aeroplane"?
  • A) Boeing 747
  • B) Old Dakota DS 088
  • C) A jet fighter
  • D) A helicopter
Correct: B) Old Dakota DS 088 — The narrator was flying an old Dakota aeroplane over France, heading to England.
3. What happened when the narrator asked the control tower about the black aeroplane?
  • A) They confirmed the pilot's identity
  • B) They said the pilot had already left
  • C) They refused to answer
  • D) They said no other aeroplane was seen on radar
Correct: D) They said no other aeroplane was seen on radar — The woman at the control tower confirmed that no other aircraft was visible on radar that stormy night, deepening the mystery.
4. In "How to Tell Wild Animals," how does the poet suggest you identify a leopard?
  • A) By its spotted hide — when it leaps on you
  • B) By its mane
  • C) By its stripes
  • D) By its long tail
Correct: A) By its spotted hide — when it leaps on you — The poet says if a beast whose "hide with spots is peppered" leaps on you, it is a leopard.
5. What does the ball symbolize in "The Ball Poem"?
  • A) Wealth and prosperity
  • B) A sports career
  • C) Childhood innocence and cherished memories
  • D) Academic achievement
Correct: C) Childhood innocence and cherished memories — The ball represents the boy's childhood, innocence, and the memories attached to it — things that cannot be replaced with money.
6. Why did the seagull's parents stop feeding him?
  • A) They did not have enough food
  • B) To force him to fly by making him desperately hungry
  • C) They forgot about him
  • D) They were angry with him
Correct: B) To force him to fly by making him desperately hungry — The parents used tough love. By starving him for 24 hours, they created a situation where hunger would overpower his fear.
7. What does "money is external" mean in "The Ball Poem"?
  • A) Money should be kept outside the house
  • B) Money is not important at all
  • C) Money belongs to banks
  • D) Money can buy objects but cannot replace emotional value
Correct: D) Money can buy objects but cannot replace emotional value — The poet means that while money can buy a new ball, it cannot restore the memories and emotional attachment the boy had with his lost ball.

Extract-Based Questions

Extract 1: "The sight of the food maddened him. With a loud, desperate cry he dived at the fish. He fell outward and downward into space."

(a) Who is 'him' and what food is being referred to?
'Him' is the young seagull. The food is a piece of fish that his mother was holding just out of his reach near the ledge.

(b) Why did the sight of food "madden" him?
The seagull had not been fed for twenty-four hours. He was desperately hungry, and seeing his mother holding fish so close yet just out of reach drove him to a point where hunger overcame his fear of flying.

(c) What happened after he "dived at the fish"?
He fell outward and downward into space. For a moment he was terrified, but then his wings spread automatically, and he began to fly. His natural instinct took over, and he discovered he had the ability to fly all along.

Extract 2: "He is learning, well behind his desperate eyes, / The epistemology of loss, how to stand up / Knowing what every man must one day know."

(a) Who is 'he' and what has he lost?
'He' is the young boy who has lost his ball. The ball bounced into the harbour and was lost forever.

(b) What is the "epistemology of loss"?
It means the knowledge and understanding of what it means to lose something. The boy is learning not just about losing a ball, but about the broader concept of loss — that things can be taken away and may never come back.

(c) What must "every man one day know"?
Every person must learn how to deal with loss and how to "stand up" — to recover, to cope, and to carry on despite losing things that are precious. This is a universal human experience.

Short Answer Questions

Q1. How did the seagull's family celebrate his first flight?

When the young seagull finally flew, his entire family was overjoyed. They screamed with delight and praised him. His mother swooped past him, his father flew over him calling encouragement. His brothers and sister circled around him, screaming and diving. They all gathered around him on the water, offering him scraps of dog-fish to eat. It was a celebration of his achievement — the entire family had worked together (through tough love) to help him overcome his fear, and now they celebrated his success together.

Q2. Compare and contrast the two flying stories — "His First Flight" and "Black Aeroplane."

Similarities: Both stories involve flying and overcoming fear. Both protagonists face a crisis in the air. Both find unexpected help — the seagull from his mother's clever trick, the pilot from the mysterious black aeroplane.

Differences: "His First Flight" is about a natural, biological first flight of a bird, while "Black Aeroplane" is about a human pilot in a mechanical aircraft. The seagull's story has a clear, realistic explanation (hunger overcame fear), while the black aeroplane story ends with an unsolved mystery. "His First Flight" is about gaining confidence and discovering one's abilities, while "Black Aeroplane" is about receiving mysterious, unexplained help. The seagull's story is warm and celebratory; the pilot's story is eerie and unsettling.

Q3. What is the significance of the title "The Ball Poem"?

The title "The Ball Poem" is deceptively simple. On the surface, it seems to be about a boy losing his ball — a trivial, everyday incident. But the ball is a symbol for much deeper themes. The ball represents childhood innocence, cherished memories, and emotional attachments. The "ball" stands for everything precious that we lose in life as we grow up. By using such a simple, everyday object as the title, the poet suggests that the most profound life lessons often come from the most ordinary experiences. The title draws the reader in with its simplicity but reveals deep philosophical meaning upon reading.

Q4. What is the irony in the poem "How to Tell Wild Animals"?

The fundamental irony is that the poem presents itself as a helpful guide to identifying wild animals, but the identification methods it describes would result in your death or serious injury. For example, you identify a lion by its roar as you are dying, a tiger by its lethal greeting, and a leopard by its attack. By the time you have "identified" the animal, it is too late. The poet Carolyn Wells uses this dark irony to create humour — the gap between the calm, instructional tone and the violent content is what makes the poem funny. It also subtly reminds us that wild animals are genuinely dangerous and should be respected from a safe distance.

Q5. Why did the narrator of "Black Aeroplane" not turn back to Paris when he saw the storm clouds?

The narrator did not turn back to Paris for two reasons. First, he was eager to get home to his family. He was dreaming of a good English breakfast and the comfort of being with his loved ones. The desire to reach home clouded his judgment. Second, he did not have enough fuel to fly around the storm clouds — they were too vast. Rather than turning back and losing time, he made the risky decision to fly straight through. This decision was driven more by emotion (homesickness, impatience) than by rational judgment, which is why it nearly proved fatal.

← Chapter 2: Nelson Mandela Chapter 4: From the Diary of Anne Frank →